Wednesday, March 02, 2005

Realism(s) In China

Realism(s) in Modern China

Through Anderson��s and Prof. Wang��s books, we are able to outline both the theory and the practice of Realism in modern China. In Anderson��s book, it is easy to consider that the debates between realistic groups of different standpoints were much eagerer and more violent than the debates between realists and romanticists. The diversity of modern Chinese Realism sometimes is not related to the poetic viewpoints of the participators but their politic positions. By reading Prof. Wang��s discussion on the lyric realism in Sheng Congwen��s fiction, the diversity of realism is manifested in the poetic aspect. First of all, I admit that I was confused by the distinction (or the ambiguity) of lyricism and romanticism. If Sheng Congwen��s fiction could be considered as ��lyricism,�� or in my understanding, lyric realism, how could he be a Realism writer? That is, if Sheng expressed his personal feeling, conveyed strong emotion or enthusiasm in his fiction, according to the definition of ��lyric,�� what is the difference between his realistic writing and Romantic writers such as Bai Wei, who shouted herself hoarse in Fight out the Ghost Tower? In my reading, Sheng Congwen��s fictions, just like the title ��Quiet,�� is quite quiet and calm in narrating tones. He never expressed his emotion excessively and most of the time we cannot recognize the implied author��s emotion in his fictions. Prof. Wang gave us the explanation my first question immediately in the begging of chapter seven in his book. Extending from Prof. Wang��s answer, in my understanding, Sheng��s fiction could be regarded as lyricism is because he expressed the emotion and collective subconsiousness of human rather his personal emotion that make his fictions lyric.

No comments: